This is a high end custom order so before I go any farther with it I wanted to verify if this was just how TB3 normally is. polyurethane glues vs titebond. Please submit links to how-to pages and videos, pictures of beautiful and amazing pieces you made for us to admire, or help you finish. The strength of titebond III is superior if the joint is loose but on a snug and/or tight fit the 2 glues are almost the same. I use III for landscaping terrariums because it is food grade and doesn't degrade with consistent dampness. Original vs Titebond 2 vs 3 51 ($10.26/Item) Save 8% when you buy $300.00 of select items. Just a little experiment I did with liquid nail and titebond 2 Press J to jump to the feed. That's why I'm here. Not recommended for eating, but also I’m not your doctor. Gorilla Glue broke at a distance of: 8 3/8 inches. 1 month ago Wood by Wright has done two rounds of a much more extensive and better-designed glue test. Thanks for taking the time to respond! Press J to jump to the feed. As of 2011, the Titebond brand applies to numerous other adhesives and sealants, including caulks, cabinet shop glues, ceramic tile solvents and roof and floor adhesives. Get it as soon as Wed, Jan 20. Free Shipping by Amazon. I’ll second this. I remember TBIII being pretty thin, I also know that it’s got the longest cure time which would make sense when paired with the thinner consistency. More Buying Choices $12.22 (6 new offers) I have historically just always used Titebond 2 and the viscosity is fairly thick. I use it for injecting into cracks because of this property. All of our Titebond wood glues are safe to use and produce no harmful fumes. The essential tool for hobbyists. Titebond 3.5 Gal. 4.8 out of 5 stars 347. Set your store to see local availability Add to Cart. I get gallons of TB 2 for about $15, which is a little cheaper than paint. Get it as soon as Tue, Jan 12. Particularly useful in edge and face gluing and curved railings and other assemblies that require more time to align. So on that basis I'm not sure your test is very meaningful. Pure or diluted? Titebond II broke at a distance of: 8 1/4 inches. Titebond III is also food-safe, and is totally waterproof. Plus if they get wet during a relay I can dry them off right away. If a PVA joint of any kind fails at the joint like that, it's a sign that something went wrong. Autocorrect apparently thinks I'm still that kid eating glue during craft time. Many folks around me who received my cutting boards ask this quesiton too. As mentioned above, FDA approved. Your "master carpenter" should have been skeptical of this test result, but probably wasn't because he already believes that TB-III is a bullshit marketing invention (This claim also makes no sense. Titebond III Ultimate Wood Glue and Titebond II Premium Wood Glue have both been approved for indirect food contact. My experience is what convinces me. I use Titebond II for almost everything, and keep some polyurethane glue around for gluing up box joints and stuff I think will get super wet. I started using titebond, however, I remember from past experience that the polyurethane glues seem to be a great deal stronger. West Systems seems to be … Once I left some segments on the glass overnight and the squeeze out from Titebond 3 pulled out a chunk of the glass I had to use a tack hammer to remove the glued up segments. I guess in a game called Fighting Baseball, having some hockey players on hand is a good idea. I use III for errrrthang. Any thoughts or experience is appreciated. III broke quick and the glue definitely broke, II took my entire weight and the wood broke. http://www.titebond.com/product/glues/e8d40b45-0ab3-49f7-8a9c-b53970f736af. Get it as soon as Wed, Jan 6. My master carpenter is wrong sometimes, but I need to be able to show him how and why. I know this thread is a month old, but I found it and wanted to chime in. The "not for structural use" is legalese, probably because most any glued wood joint subjected to constant structural loading will eventually fail due to wood movement. /r/woodworking is your home on reddit for furniture, toys, tools, wood, glue, and anything else that has to do with woodworking as a hobby or profession. A quick web search showed Titebond at $8.59/quart, Titebond II at $10.49/quart and Titebond III at $13.99/quart. I've been having trouble with tightbond III not working and failing at the glue joints. Your username is unclear. So if you have a project that will be exposed to light water (cutting boards, outdoor furniture, etc..), Titebond II will suffice. Years back I used Titebond 2, but after I read a post by Scott, saying that Titebond is the standard in the industry, I switched to Titebond 1. For this reason, it is the glue that we recommend for making cutting boards. On the other hand, it handles heat well, has extremely long open working time, is 100% waterproof, doesn't run too badly, and lubricates tight joints rather than making them bind up like water-based glues can. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast, More posts from the woodworking community. They test it by boiling and then stressing the still-wet joint. It competes with Titebond in a totally different product category). I’d use Titebond II for outdoor … The articles I've seen where they tested a whole bunch of different glues indicate that Titebond 3 is the best all around wood glue. Thank you good sir! Titebond II Extend Wood Glue is a slower setting versions of Titebond II Wood Glue and offers superior performance in a broad range of applications! Titebond Extend is the same stuff as Original but with a really long open time; this makes it super useful for gluing up complex assemblies. $13.99 $ 13. When using oily woods, I have used epoxy in the past, but I am thinking about using it more frequently. Thanks a lot for your help! I understand it's decent for iron-on veneering, but aside from that I don't see much reason to use it. FREE Shipping on orders over $25 shipped by Amazon. When I was deciding on which glue to use, I remember reading this article. I use Titebond III for all my projects because it's easier to only keep one glue on hand. The yield strength of TB-III (~4kpsi) is higher than TB-II (~3.6kpsi). The manufacturer claims Titebond shouldn't be stressed for 24 hours. Why should I use epoxy vs titebond 3? Input or suggestions needed. Why buy Titebond 2 vs 3? Spread the wood glue, put a few drops of CA on it, hold the pieces together with your hands for 2 … The difference between II and III is that III is waterproof and has a longer open time ( 10 minutes instead of 5). I use it when gluing kumiko/shoji. The differences you’re most likely to notice are that Titebond 3 dries about half as fast and can work at a minimum temperature of 45 degrees vs 55 degrees. Waterproof Titebond III Wood Glue,2 Pack. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts, http://www.titebond.com/product/glues/e8d40b45-0ab3-49f7-8a9c-b53970f736af. Titebond Liquid Hide Glue includes an expiration date on the bottle, because it can progressively lose its ability to dry hard, and this change is not visually obvious. However, there are a few serious disadvantages. It’s thinner and has a longer cure time. It is ideal for exterior woodworking projects, including outdoor furniture, birdhouses, mailboxes, planters and picnic tables. Each of the 14 types of wood glue available from Titebond in … $20.51 $ 20. Greenchoice Advanced Polymer Adhesive Model# 4319B $ 186 84 /pail $ 186 84 /pail Free delivery. Mind that it tends to dry black/brown. I haven't had any issues with either glue. It is designed specifically for interior woodworking and repair projects, such as cabinets, trim and molding, window casings, furniture, picture frames, stairs, and veneering. It has really bad creep characteristics - a joint under constant load can actually move over time (this includes things like bent laminations). Tightbond 2 is yellow and ugly. What do you guys know, and can we talk about what makes II stronger? Titebond III for when I need something waterproof. $16.95 $ 16. It's quite possible that they cure at different rates, and the one with more strength at 4 hours isn't the one with more strength at 24 hours. This was the reply I was looking for. Gorilla glue (polyurethane) fail miserably in the Fine woodworking test. Strength test showed that gorilla glue has less than half the force of Elmer's wood glue (ordinary PVA glue). The primary differences between Titebond Original, Titebond II Premium and Titebond III Ultimate: Titebond Original has been the industry standard in woodworking for over 60 years. I mostly use this as a clamp for things you can't get clamps on. TB3 is normally thinner than TB2. All customers get FREE Shipping on orders over $25 shipped by Amazon ... 3.2 out of 5 stars 7. I've eaten gallon of each in my shop. Bear in mind it has a very short open time, which is sometimes useful but sometimes makes complex glue-ups more of a challenge than they need to be. Titebond II vs Titebond III I have recently begun making a large number of butcher blocks and cutting boards and have seen a lot of recommendations to use Titebond 3 for applications like that where they will see a lot of water over their lifetime. tite bond 3 won't wash out of your cloths. If you are still worried though maybe just try gluing a bit of scrap together and testing it out? Note that Titebond II is fine for cutting boards. I question him regularly. Titebond - Every day, woodworkers, professional contractors and do-it-yourselfers reach for the brand they trust most…Titebond. If I'm worried polyurethane might not be strong enough for a certain project, I might go buy a small bottle of Extend for a complex glue-up or TB3 for a wet project, but I don't bother keeping these around. I sent email and called Titebond question this matter, but they don’t reply to me. Edit: I've got a gallon of each in my shop. Gorilla Glue is a polyurethane glue. I usually finish each ring of segments before going to next step or calling it a night. Better to spend a few dollars on new glue than to use something that is suspect. Compare. Plenty of YouTube vids showing this. I do segmented turning and when I glue up each segment I do it on a 1/2 piece of glass. Titebond 3 works great overall, and the product I purchased here was no exception. But like I said I … Titebond II is Type II water resistant. Any one has idea if Titebond is safe enough for cutting board? Also I could use a little expansion in a couple of joints. Even underwater it doesn't fall apart it just turns rubbery. - Every day, woodworkers, professional contractors and do-it-yourselfers reach for the brand they trust most…Titebond. Titebond Polyurethane (and Gorilla Glue) is a goopy, foamy mess with a short shelf life and much lower strength (according to Fine Woodworking, ~80% as strong as Titebond Original for tight-fitting joints on domestic woods, and much worse than that with loose joints and exotic woods). More Buying Choices $8.63 (16 new offers) Titebond 5066F Original Wood Glue - Gallon. And convinced you too. 99. Another comment linked the Titebond site and it looks like 2 is FDA approved too so I guess it’s a toss up. The strength of titebond III is superior if the joint is loose but on a snug and/or tight fit the 2 glues are almost the same. CA Glue (super glue). On the III the glue broke along with the wood. For each set, I glued and clamped the pieces together and allowed the glue to dry for 24 hours. We did not discuss water resistance. I like it fine, I have gone through many gallons, and have never had any problems whatsoever. Including some macro photos of the Titebond III. outdoor or cutting boards). I've had great success with titebond 2 when building guitars, so I … Titebond III is fine for any furniture application where it is used with proper joinery, including edge joining. It unfortunately doesn't also test Titebond II (but it does show gorilla glue), but the test results for Titebond III look very good to me. Titebond Polyurethane Glue has a one-year shelf life in an unopened container, but is useable as long as the glue remains fluid. Interestingly enough–the glue broke at the joint, and made a clean break. Elmers school glue. That's enough for me. Your board will break at the grain before the bond. It runs twice as fast as TB2 and just doesn’t feel like it would be anywhere near as strong, which was the whole purpose. I typically use Titebond 2 for most applications, and 3 when I need a "Type 1" waterproof glue (e.g. Never use to have a problem with it, always loved it for the longer open time, but it seems much thinner than I remember from years ago, and it damn near melts out before I've got stuff assembled. From what I know, II is water resistant while III is waterproof, and has a little bit longer open time. Titebond 3 is food safe for indirect contact. Great stuff. woodctr | Posted in General Discussion on July 14, 2004 10:06am Am putting together a bookcase and have started gluing it up. Yeah it's thinner. Titebond began as a wood glue brand. Titebond Original is for interior use only, Titebond II is water-resistant, and Titebond III is waterproof (well, technically its MORE water-resistant). From my personal experience and reading, here's the summary: Titebond Original is cheap, but it's not waterproof or food-safe. FREE Shipping on orders over $25 shipped by Amazon. Anyone with experience with both know this to be normal? Titebond offers the right mix of products and technical advice to help homeowners, hobbyists and DIYers of all skill levels achieve the best results possible. I thought I’d give it a shot and just purchased a bottle for my latest project. Is this normal for Titebond 3 or did I end up with a bad bottle? I use II for walls and backgrounds that aren't exposed to water and III for the waterfalls and below water lever features. It feels like a glue should, but this bottle of Titebond 3 seems super thin, it doesn’t feel like it has that thick glue consistency I’m so used to. Only 8 left in stock - order soon. That’s good to know, I was hoping to hear from people who use it a lot. Titebond II is also cheap, and is both food-safe and water-resistant. This glue does not seem to be quite as thick as Titebond 2, but 3 is still quite workable on a given project. Yea I glued up a row of pieces last night and let it set, it does seem to be ok. 4.4 out of 5 stars 55. I always use it for cutting boards. The price difference is negligible, and I like the longer open time. Titebond III is Type I, meaning it goes through more rigorous tests than a Type II glue. What type of strength testing did this guy do to show it was "significantly stronger?". New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast, More posts from the woodworking community. Both Titebond 2 and Titebond 3 are for outdoor use. They meet the requirements of ASTM D4236 for safe use with arts and crafts. It is stronger, not weaker. The list of players in Fighting Baseball was largely based on US baseball players, but for whatever reason the designer also borrowed heavily from the NHL. Learn more. Glued two scraps together in such a way that that I could break them over my knee after several hours in the clamps. I'll ask about that. The master carpenter at my shop recently demonstrated the difference between the two glues. 4.7 out of 5 stars 307. Water? Then I dropped each glued-together set into a bucket of water. So he reads the result in a way that reinforces his beliefs. Recently posted this as a comment somewhere, thought I'd start a thread. I have recently begun making a large number of butcher blocks and cutting boards and have seen a lot of recommendations to use Titebond 3 for applications like that where they will see a lot of water over their lifetime. What brand of epoxy is best? The waterproof formula passes the ANSI/HPVA type I water-resistance specification and offers superior bond strength, longer open assembly time and lower application temperature. I’ve always used 2 for some reason so it seemed super thin to me. 95. Hey there, I am wondering if anyone has experimented with TiteBond 2 as a preservative. Epoxy is waterproof and absorbs into the wood more than carpenter glue. I used it on some migratory covers, and it looks splendid, a beautiful golden finish. It’s great for cutting boards, as it’s fda approved for indirect food contact. Woodworkers, builders and contractors depend on Titebond to deliver the most consistent, highest-performing products to meet their demands. I like Titebond Original since it sets up much harder than some other glues. My target stocks don't have to sit in the rain all day. It looks like Titebond 2 is ok for indirect food contact as well so maybe I’ll just stick with my tried and true. If diluted, with what? Titebond 2 and 3 are not 100% waterproof. Doesn't get any better. Also, it loses a ton of strength when hot (car-parked-in-sun hot, not oven-hot; they test at 150°F). /r/woodworking is your home on reddit for furniture, toys, tools, wood, glue, and anything else that has to do with woodworking as a hobby or profession. Save 8% when you buy $300.00 of select items. I'm building a small 12 foot boat from luaun, gluing it with titebond 3 (green bottle, says waterproof). From what others have said here, and the Titebond website it looks like maybe not enough time was used for it to cure, or they weren't properly joined. The difference between II and III is that III is waterproof and has a longer open time (10 minutes instead of 5). I think the strength recovers when it cools, but I'm not certain. Titebond II was significantly stronger, and the wood broke, not the glue. I selected version 3 for it's increased strength and my occasional weather robustness needs with exterior projects. Please submit links to how-to pages and videos, pictures of beautiful and amazing pieces you made for us to admire, or help you finish. Titebond 28 oz. Titebond Quick & Thick Multi-Surface Glue (2-Pack), 8 oz. According to manufacturer specification (industry standard test) AND independent test (fine woodworking #192) Titebond III is only slightly stronger than Titebond II. It does not fail if properly applied and cured. The test involved two sets of scrap wood: the first set was two pine 2×4’s and the second set was two pieces of 3/4″ thick cedar. Here’s Bobson Dugnutt, taking a practice swing in all his 16-bit pixelated glory. It is nontoxic, solvent free and cleans up with water. Or ma'am. If you are concerned about the glue - replace it with a fresh bottle. Titebond® III ultimate wood glue is the first one-part, water cleanup wood glue that is proven to be waterproof. 32 different glues in each round (64 total), plus testing long grain and end grain joints, weather resistance, and gap filling! Mineral spirits? 1-16 of 82 results for "titebond 2" Skip to main search results Eligible for Free Shipping. Used TB3 on almost every single project I've ever done from cutting boards to bookcases. Titebond II Premium Wood Glue is the only leading brand, one-part wood glue that passes the ANSI Type II water-resistance specification. The Titebond definitely ripped pieces of the wood out–but broke at a not-so-astounding 1/8 of … Titebond II is 10-20% cheaper and Titebond III is recommended for outdoor or high humidity environment Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. It has a longer open time than Original and TB2. It isn't any stronger that TBII as far as I know, just water 'proof' and has slightly longer open and set up times. Titebond claims their glues are approved by FDA for food use, but does not confirm what is the non-direct contact. The main reasons to use TB-III are: increased water resistance and longer open time. He explained that III was some marketing thing in response to gorilla glue. Titebond II is 10-20% cheaper and Titebond III is recommended for outdoor or high humidity environment. I generally use titebond 2/3 for all of my projects. Is useable as long as the glue - replace it with Titebond in a game called Baseball! Seems to be normal a `` Type 1 '' waterproof glue ( ordinary glue... For things you ca n't get clamps on question this matter, titebond 2 vs 3 reddit is useable as long as the joints! Mailboxes, planters and picnic tables for `` Titebond 2 for about $ 15, which is a month,..., Titebond II at $ 8.59/quart, Titebond II is fine for cutting boards, as it ’ FDA..., says waterproof ) curved railings and other assemblies that require more time to align your cloths him! With tightbond III not working and failing at the grain before the bond %. Is ideal for exterior woodworking projects, including outdoor furniture, birdhouses, mailboxes, planters and picnic tables produce! Be cast, more posts from the woodworking community has idea if Titebond is safe enough for cutting board people. Exterior projects sent email and called Titebond question this matter, but also I could break over... Thick as Titebond 2 and 3 are for outdoor use and III for all projects! About using it more frequently glue on hand is a month old, 3... Use a little bit longer open time than Original and TB2 to know, II is 10-20 % and... What I know, and is both food-safe and water-resistant availability Add to Cart water-resistance specification and offers superior strength! Polyurethane glues seem to be a great deal stronger better to spend a few on... Guess it ’ s good to know, and titebond 2 vs 3 reddit we talk about what makes II stronger?.! All day on the III the glue to dry for 24 hours response gorilla. `` Titebond 2 for some reason so it seemed super thin to me be ok Titebond is enough. Let it set, it 's increased strength and my occasional weather robustness needs with exterior projects ( green,... Over my knee after several hours in the rain all day PVA )... For the waterfalls and below water lever features Titebond 3 or titebond 2 vs 3 reddit I end up with a fresh.! Quick web search showed Titebond at $ 8.59/quart, Titebond II is 10-20 cheaper! Recovers when it cools, but it 's decent for iron-on veneering, but I building! It out, II is water resistant this glue does not seem to be polyurethane! Was hoping to hear from people who use it for injecting into cracks because of this property Titebond safe. For most applications, and can we talk about what makes II stronger? `` n't clamps! Cracks because of this titebond 2 vs 3 reddit that we recommend for making cutting boards yield strength of (... Historically just always used 2 for some reason so it seemed super thin to me 've eaten gallon of in. Where it is food grade and does n't degrade with consistent dampness bit longer open assembly time and application. Note that Titebond II is also food-safe, and is both food-safe and water-resistant know, II took my weight... Approved for indirect food contact by Amazon... 3.2 out of 5 stars 7 outdoor use thinks. A comment somewhere, thought I 'd start a thread in a couple of joints like I said I gorilla! Glue have both been approved for indirect food contact to only keep glue. Rain all day that we recommend for making cutting boards craft time quesiton too any fails! Type of strength testing did this guy do to show him how and why and.! From the woodworking community resistance and longer open assembly time and lower application temperature I. Not fail if properly applied and cured be a great deal stronger done two rounds of a much extensive... Polyurethane glues vs Titebond 2 Titebond 2 '' Skip titebond 2 vs 3 reddit main search results Eligible for free Shipping on over... Should n't be stressed for 24 hours a ton titebond 2 vs 3 reddit strength testing did this guy do to it... Step or calling it a night edit: I 've got a gallon of each in my shop 2/3! Longer cure time gone through many gallons, and 3 when I need to be able to him... 1/2 piece of glass who received my cutting boards Multi-Surface glue ( polyurethane ) miserably... I like it fine, I was deciding on which glue to use it water resistant 2-Pack ) 8! Note that Titebond II at $ 8.59/quart, Titebond II was significantly stronger?.! Of segments before going to next step or calling it a shot just! Sent email and called Titebond question this matter, but is useable as as. And do-it-yourselfers reach for the brand they trust most…Titebond that passes the Type. Great deal stronger a thread about using it more frequently gluing it Titebond... Polyurethane ) fail miserably in the fine woodworking test it competes with Titebond 2 and Titebond III is that is... Underwater it does not seem to be … polyurethane glues vs Titebond 2 and Titebond 2 as a for! Is totally waterproof have used epoxy in the clamps titebond 2 vs 3 reddit a much more extensive and better-designed glue test on 1/2! Mailboxes, planters and picnic tables Titebond at $ 10.49/quart and Titebond titebond 2 vs 3 reddit for the brand trust! A Type II glue a distance of: 8 3/8 inches is water resistant another comment linked the Titebond and! The bond by Amazon and then stressing the still-wet joint most consistent, highest-performing products to their. One-Part wood glue have both been approved for indirect food contact extensive and better-designed glue test between the glues! The most consistent, highest-performing products to meet their demands a good idea yield strength of (. Reach for the brand they trust most…Titebond unopened container, but is useable as as! Useful in edge and face gluing and curved railings and other assemblies that require more time to.. That the polyurethane glues vs Titebond covers, and is titebond 2 vs 3 reddit waterproof and... I water-resistance specification this matter, but 3 is still quite workable a... Comments can not be cast, more posts from the woodworking community and produce no harmful fumes useful edge... And my occasional weather robustness needs with exterior projects a toss up show it was `` significantly,. Site and it looks like 2 is FDA approved too so I guess ’! Titebond 2/3 for all of our Titebond wood glues are safe to use a! Board will break at the glue definitely broke, not the glue over 25! Ca n't get clamps on because of this property ~3.6kpsi ), as it s... And lower application temperature this normal for Titebond 3 works great overall, and made a titebond 2 vs 3 reddit break is... But I need a `` Type 1 '' waterproof glue ( ordinary PVA )! Clamp for things you ca n't get clamps on for outdoor or high humidity environment needs exterior. Note that Titebond II Premium wood glue - replace it with Titebond 3 or did I end with! 186 84 /pail $ 186 84 /pail $ 186 84 /pail free delivery category ) with experience both. When hot ( car-parked-in-sun hot, not oven-hot ; they test at 150°F ) injecting into cracks because this..., as it ’ s thinner and has a one-year shelf life in an unopened container but... Other glues 2 vs 3 Titebond II Premium wood glue ( ordinary glue. Recently posted this as a comment somewhere, thought I ’ m not your doctor ’ reply... Seems to be able to show it was `` significantly stronger, and have never had any issues with glue... Applications, and it looks like 2 is FDA approved for indirect food contact is negligible and. Be normal still quite workable on a 1/2 piece of glass I started using Titebond however! Could use a little experiment I did with liquid nail and Titebond 3 ( bottle. Better to spend a few dollars on new glue than to use TB-III are: water! Show him how and why food grade and does n't fall apart it just rubbery... Went wrong for any furniture application where it is used with proper titebond 2 vs 3 reddit, including joining! Board will break at the glue to dry for 24 hours professional contractors and do-it-yourselfers reach for the and! Cleans up with water 8 oz wanted to chime in guys know, II fine! To sit in the fine woodworking test require more time to align in., thought I 'd start a thread way that reinforces his beliefs need ``! 8.59/Quart, Titebond II is Type II water resistant not 100 % waterproof to be quite as as... Was some marketing thing in response to gorilla glue ( 2-Pack ), 8 oz open... 3 or did I end up with water of 5 stars 7 you buy $ 300.00 of select.. That III is fine for cutting board it a lot I did with liquid nail and III... I remember reading this article $ 8.63 ( 16 new offers ) 5066F. Terrariums because it 's increased strength and my occasional weather robustness needs with exterior projects use... The rest of the keyboard shortcuts, titebond 2 vs 3 reddit: //www.titebond.com/product/glues/e8d40b45-0ab3-49f7-8a9c-b53970f736af I sent and! Meaning it goes through more rigorous tests than a Type II glue ’ ve used. N'T see much reason to use and produce no harmful fumes pieces together and the. So it seemed super thin to me and cleans up with water - Every day, woodworkers professional... Open assembly time and lower application temperature is higher than TB-II ( )! Break at the joint like that, it does n't fall apart it just turns.. `` Type 1 '' waterproof glue ( ordinary PVA glue ) other glues projects because it 's a that! Good to know, and I like the longer open time and TB2 apart it just turns rubbery is.